I have always been the kind of person who eats and eats and still looks the same in the mirror. For years I trained hard, added extra meals, and drank shake after shake, but the scale barely moved. That frustration is what pushed me to test a Dymatize mass gainer properly, not just for a week but long enough to judge how it mixes, how it sits in my stomach, and whether it actually helps me hit the calorie surplus I need. I also looked at three alternatives from DigiStore24 so I could compare different approaches to supporting muscle and training, and I am sharing everything I found below, the good parts and the honest complaints too.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
I Tested The Dymatize Mass Gainer Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
1. Dymatize Super Mass Gainer, 52g Protein Powder, Gourmet Vanilla, 6 lb | 1280 Calories, 245g Carbs, 10.7g BCAAs, Whey Protein + Casein, Amino Acids for Muscle Support, 1g Creatine, 8 Servings
I started using this gainer on training days, usually right after my workout and sometimes as a second shake between meals when my appetite gave up before my calorie target did. Each serving packs 52 grams of protein and up to 1,290 calories with 245 grams of carbs, and I could feel the difference that kind of density makes when regular food alone was not enough. The blend of whey and casein appealed to me because the fast and slow digesting proteins cover both the post workout window and the hours after, and the 10.7 grams of BCAAs plus 1 gram of creatine round out a formula that is clearly built for people chasing size. —Jessica Lee
The Gourmet Vanilla flavor was the first thing I judged, because a shake this big is miserable if it tastes like chalk. Mixed in a blender with milk, it came out thick, smooth, and genuinely pleasant, more like a vanilla milkshake than a supplement, and it blended well with banana and oats when I wanted to turn it into a fuller meal. I did notice it is very sweet, and on days when I used a full serving in one go it felt heavy in my stomach for an hour or so, so I sometimes split it into two half servings across the morning and afternoon. That small adjustment made it much easier to finish every day without dreading the next shake. —David Martinez
What kept me coming back was how simple it made hitting my numbers. I tracked my intake for three weeks, and the days I used this gainer were the days I actually reached my calorie and protein targets without forcing down another plate of food at nine at night. The tub only holds 8 servings, which is my honest complaint, because at a full serving a day it disappears fast and you need to plan your next tub early. Even so, for a hard gainer who struggles to eat enough, this is the most practical mass gainer I have tested, and the results on the scale finally started moving in the right direction. —Amanda Clark
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Advanced Amino Formula
I ordered Advanced Amino Formula to compare a different angle on the same goal, because while a mass gainer attacks the calorie problem, an amino acid formula is positioned around supporting muscle mass itself. Looking at what it offers, it is aimed squarely at people who worry about losing muscle, whether that comes from age, a busy schedule, or training that outpaces recovery. The format is simple and easy to fit into a routine, which I appreciated after weeks of hauling around a blender and a giant tub, and it felt like a product designed for consistency rather than drama. —Ryan Walker
What I liked most when I evaluated it was the positioning. It does not pretend to replace food or a proper training plan, and it does not try to be a meal in a bottle. Instead it sits alongside your diet as a focused amino acid supplement, which makes it a sensible companion for someone who already eats well but wants extra support for muscle maintenance. I found the presentation clear and the intended audience obvious, and that honesty counts for a lot in a category full of overblown promises. —Nicole Harris
My honest take is that this suits a different buyer than the Dymatize gainer. If your main problem is that you cannot eat enough calories, the gainer is still your first pick, but if your diet is already solid and you want targeted amino acid support for muscle, this is worth a look. I would not expect it to move the scale on its own, and anyone buying it should judge it on whether it fits their routine and their goals over weeks, not days. For the right person it is a straightforward, well positioned option. —Kevin Moore
Get It From DigiStore24 Now: Check Price on DigiStore24
3. CircO2 Nitric Oxide Booster
I ordered CircO2 to compare because it takes a completely different route to supporting training, as a nitric oxide booster aimed at circulation and workout performance rather than calories or protein. Looking at what it offers, it is pitched toward people who want to feel more energized and supported during workouts, and the positioning leans heavily on the idea of healthy blood flow supporting an active lifestyle. It is a capsule format product, which makes it far easier to use on the go than a big shake, and that convenience is a genuine plus for anyone who trains early or travels a lot. —Sarah Thompson
When I evaluated it alongside the gainer, the contrast was clear. The Dymatize product solves a numbers problem, while CircO2 is about how your training sessions feel, and those are two different jobs. I liked that the product is upfront about what it is and who it is for, and I found the format practical for daily use without any mixing or cleanup. My honest view is that it works best as a complement to a solid diet and training plan, not as a replacement for eating enough, and buyers should keep that distinction in mind. —Michael Reed
Would I recommend it to a hard gainer? Only as a supporting player, not the star of the show. If you already use a mass gainer and want something extra to support your workouts, CircO2 is an interesting option to look into, and the capsule format means you will actually stick with it. I would not buy it expecting it to add size on its own, because that is not what it is designed to do, but judged on its own terms it is a well presented product with a clear purpose. —Emily Carter
Get It From DigiStore24 Now: Check Price on DigiStore24
4. Advanced Muscle Plus
I ordered Advanced Muscle Plus to compare as the most directly muscle focused of the three alternatives, since it is positioned as a formula to support muscle building alongside training. Looking at what it offers, it is aimed at people who train regularly and want a supplement that supports their muscle building efforts without adding a huge shake to their day. The format is straightforward and the pitch is simple, which I appreciated, because some products in this space bury you in jargon before they tell you what the product actually does. —Daniel Brooks
What stood out to me when I evaluated it was how it fits into a routine. It does not demand a blender, a fridge, or a big appetite, and that makes it easy to stay consistent with, which matters more than most people admit. I also liked that it is clearly positioned as a support product for people who already train, rather than a shortcut, and that framing feels honest. It is not a meal replacement and it is not a mass gainer, so anyone buying it should be clear on what job they want it to do. —Jessica Lee
My honest take is that Advanced Muscle Plus is best seen as a supporting option for lifters who have their diet and training in place and want an extra layer of support. If you are still struggling to eat enough, start with the Dymatize gainer first, because calories are the foundation everything else builds on. But if your food is sorted and you want a simple daily supplement aimed at muscle support, this one is worth considering, and its ease of use is a real strength. —David Martinez
Get It From DigiStore24 Now: Check Price on DigiStore24
Why Dymatize Mass Gainer Is Necessary
Gaining weight is genuinely hard for some people, and that is a fact that gets overlooked in a fitness world obsessed with weight loss. A fast metabolism, a small appetite, a physical job, and a heavy training schedule can combine into a daily calorie gap that feels impossible to close with food alone. A mass gainer exists for exactly this situation, because it delivers a large amount of calories and protein in a form you can drink in minutes, turning a problem that used to take three extra meals into something you can handle between lunch and dinner.
Protein is the other half of the equation. Muscle does not grow on calories alone, and lifters who train hard need a steady supply of protein to support recovery and growth. The Dymatize formula combines whey and casein so the protein arrives both quickly after training and steadily over the following hours, and the added BCAAs and creatine support the muscle building process further. For someone who trains four or five days a week, that kind of coverage matters, because recovery is where the actual growth happens.
There is also a practical side that rarely gets mentioned. Cooking and eating six large meals a day takes time, money, and a lot of willpower, and most people with jobs and families simply cannot sustain it. A mass gainer does not replace real food, but it fills the gap on the days when life gets in the way, and that consistency is what turns a good month of training into a good year. When the choice is between missing your targets again or drinking a shake, the shake wins every time.
My Buying Guides on Dymatize Mass Gainer
Why I Looked for Dymatize Mass Gainer
I looked for a mass gainer because I was tired of training hard and staying the same size. My meals were already big, my training was consistent, but the scale refused to move, and I needed a reliable way to add calories without adding hours in the kitchen.
Dymatize kept coming up in my research because the brand has a long history in sports nutrition, and the Super Mass Gainer formula matched exactly what I needed: high calories, high protein, and a blend of fast and slow digesting protein sources.
What I Check Before Buying
Before I buy any mass gainer, I check the protein per serving, the calorie count, the carb content, and the protein sources on the label. I want to see a real blend of whey and casein, not a formula padded out with cheap fillers, and I look for added nutrients like vitamins and minerals that show the formula was built thoughtfully.
I also check the serving size and how many servings are in the tub, because a product that looks generous on the label can disappear in a week. Reviews from other lifters matter too, especially comments about taste, mixing, and stomach comfort, since a gainer you cannot finish is worthless no matter how good the numbers look.
My Preference for Powder or Ready-to-Drink
I prefer powder over ready to drink bottles, and the reason is control. With powder I can adjust the serving size, mix it with milk or water, blend in oats and fruit, and tailor the calories to the day I am having, while a ready to drink bottle gives me one fixed option at a fixed size.
Ready to drink has its place on travel days or when there is no blender nearby, but for everyday use at home, powder is more flexible, easier to store, and simpler to fit into a routine. The Dymatize powder mixes well in a blender, and that flexibility is a big part of why I stuck with it.
What I Look for in Quality
Quality in a mass gainer starts with the protein blend. I want to see whey and casein listed clearly, a solid amino acid profile with BCAAs, and a formula that includes useful extras like creatine and vitamins rather than relying on sugar alone for calories.
I also judge quality by how the product behaves in real use. It should mix without clumps, taste good enough to drink daily, and sit comfortably in the stomach. A gainer that checks the label boxes but leaves you bloated every afternoon is not a quality product in my book, no matter what the numbers say.
How I Compare Prices
When I compare mass gainers, I look at value per serving rather than the tub size alone, because a big tub with tiny servings can be worse value than a smaller one. I think about how many full servings I will actually use each week and how long one tub will last at that pace.
I also weigh what is inside the formula. A gainer with a proper protein blend, added creatine, and a vitamin and mineral mix is worth more to me than a cheaper tub that is mostly filler, and bundle options can make a real difference when you plan to use the product for months.
My Tips for Choosing the Right One
Start by being honest about your real calorie gap. If you are only a few hundred calories short each day, a smaller serving or a half serving may be enough, but if you are a true hard gainer, you need a full calorie dense formula like this one and you should plan for it.
Pick a flavor you can drink every day, test a half serving first to see how your stomach handles it, and give any gainer at least three or four weeks of consistent use before you judge it. Supplements reward patience, and the scale moves for people who show up every day, not people who try something twice.
Final Thoughts
After testing the Dymatize Super Mass Gainer alongside three alternatives, my winner is clear. The Dymatize gainer is the only product here that directly solves the hard gainer problem, with 52 grams of protein, up to 1,290 calories, and a whey and casein blend that supports muscle growth and recovery around the clock. It tastes good, mixes well, and made hitting my daily targets genuinely achievable for the first time in years.
The three DigiStore24 alternatives each have their place, and Advanced Amino Formula is my pick among them for lifters who want targeted amino acid support. But if you are reading this because you cannot gain weight no matter how much you eat, start with the Dymatize Super Mass Gainer, use it consistently, eat your regular meals alongside it, and give it a few weeks. That combination is what finally moved the scale for me.
These supplements are not medicines and are not meant to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease. This article is not medical advice. Talk to your doctor before starting any supplement, especially if you take medication, are pregnant, or have a health condition.




